Amendment of SG Patents after Grant
Quote from premium on December 17, 2021, 1:39 pmI have heard that there can be difficulties arising from amending an SG patent after grant, if that is done too late.
What is the problem?
I have heard that there can be difficulties arising from amending an SG patent after grant, if that is done too late.
What is the problem?
Quote from Martin Schweiger on December 17, 2021, 1:44 pmIt is true that once a Singapore patent is granted, the patent owner has a duty to amend his patent if he becomes aware of a possibly relevant prior art.
If the patent owner does not comply with this duty, the Registrar or a Court may at a later time - e.g. during infringement proceedings - not allow the Singapore patent to be amended anymore. A delay of only six months between having knowledge of such a prior art in any other country and a request for amending the corresponding Singapore patent may already be too long.
This is not a theoretical case. We have recently destroyed an SG patent by challenging the late amendment request of its owner, see here:
http://www.supremecourt.gov.sg/docs/default-source/module-document/judgement/ship-s-equipment-centre-bremen-gmbh-v-fuji-trading-%28singapore%29-pte-ltd-and-others-and-another-suit.pdfTherefore, all relevant prior art, search reports, and examination reports, their replies and decisions, particularly of all patents in the same patent family need to be taken into account on a regular basis.
We would recommend adapting the SG patent to the relevant prior art when the last patent application of the patent family member has been granted or abandoned.
In any case, amendment of the SG patent according to any potentially relevant prior art should be done before any infringement proceedings out of the granted SG patent against third parties.
Just to give you a heads-up, it is often not trivial to decide which amendment should be duplicated in the granted Singapore patent and which not. For example, if the foreign corresponding independent claim has been limited by a feature that is taken up from the description, the Singapore patent should be amended as well. On the other hand, if the foreign corresponding independent claim has been limited by a feature that is taken up from a dependent claim that is also present in the SG patent then an amendment of the SG patent claims may not be necessary.